← Back to Insights

Private Client Case study

A denied BMW claim. A full-value recovery in two days.

Virtus challenged an unsupported claim denial, helping a client recover the full value of a totaled BMW and avoid a $5,000 deductible.

Originally published November 15, 2026

A graphite luxury sedan parked beside a winding, tree-lined road

The challenge

A client left a new BMW at a dealership for repairs. While a dealership employee was driving the car back to the client’s home, the driver reported hitting a deer, and the vehicle was declared a total loss.

The dealership’s insurer denied the claim. Its position was that a collision with a wild animal involved no negligence, so no one was at fault. Without intervention, the client faced a $5,000 deductible and a loss on their own claims history in a difficult personal auto market.

The strategy

Virtus’ claims team started by asking the adjuster what evidence supported the denial. The insurer could not produce any: there was no police report, no investigation, and no supporting documentation.

The team also challenged the insurer’s view of fault. Virtus argued that the dealership was responsible for the vehicle while it was in its care and that a reported deer collision did not, by itself, establish that the driver had no responsibility. The driver had also taken a winding scenic route rather than the direct highway to the client’s home.

The client then learned from the local police that the report number the dealership had provided did not exist. Virtus raised this with the adjuster by phone and email the same day, calling the basis for the denial into question. The insurer reviewed the claim internally and agreed to extend coverage.

Virtus also advised the client that, in this claim, they were owed rental reimbursement for a comparable luxury vehicle for the full period they were without the car, even though they had other vehicles available.

The results

Within two days, the insurer agreed to pay the full value of the client’s BMW. The client also secured rental reimbursement for the entire time they were without the vehicle.

Because the claim was paid by the dealership’s insurer, the client avoided their $5,000 deductible and kept the loss off their own claims history.

Facing a claim denial that doesn’t add up? Talk with our team about how claims advocacy can help you pursue the outcome you’re owed.

This article provides general information. Coverage depends on the terms of your policy and the facts of a claim.